The donner party, illfated settlers turned to cannibalism. The group was named for the expeditions captain, george donner. The 84 members of the donner party, trapped by a sierra nevada snowstorm on their way to california, did not resort to cannibalism, according to a new analysis of bones found at their alder creek campsite. If the donner party did resort to cannibalism, the bones were treated in a different way such as buried. Of the nearly 90 members who left illinois, only around 45 made it to california. Archaeological findings at the alder creek camp proved inconclusive for evidence of cannibalism. Mormons and the donner party america, church, lds, quote. Bones of contention donner party archeology tahoe weekly. Did members of the donner party eat each other to survive. Theres no physical evidence that the family who gave the donner party its name had anything to do with the cannibalism the illfated pioneers have been associated with for a. The second relief party reached the lake on march 1 and found the unsettling remains of cannibalism. Donner party cannibalism wasnt a myth its evidence that starving humans will eat each other.
Cannibalism in the donner party is not in question. The donner party was a group of american settlers heading to california who became stranded in heavy snows in the sierra nevada mountains in 1846. There are plenty of these cases found in fairly recent history. Donner party, group of american pioneers stranded en route to california.
Hoping to make the sacramento valley by autumn, they fell behind schedule after taking an untried shortcut through the great salt lake desert. Todays entry in our ongoing look at famous diary entries is a dark one. But even stories of the donner party s survival cannibalism cant be verified. Some of the migrants reso rted to cann ibalism to survive, eating the bodies of those who had succumbed to starvation and sickness. Using csi methods, they examined bone remains and found that 1 the donner family camp was at a different site from the camp where cannibalism demonstrably occurred, and 2 theres no evidence. How lewis keseberg was branded the killer cannibal of the. It was a mixture of poor planning, a series of bad decisions, and early snowstorms that caused 60 of the original pioneers to become stranded in the mountains during the winter of. Instead of each other, anthropologists say the donner party probably ate cattle, deer, horse and dog and did their best to maintain a civilized l. And when recent excavations of a donner campsite at nearby alder creek found no clear evidence of the taboo, initial news reports suggested.
What we have demonstrated is that there is no evidence for cannibalism, said robbins. Some of the most substantial proof comes from the survivors themselves. The donner party was a group of american pioneers who migrated to. An absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, said kristin johnson, a salt lake citybased donner historian and editor of several books containing primary sources about the donner party. While cannibalism may indeed be part of the donner party story, the alder creek excavations help reveal the more complicated truth behind. When the others food ran out, they reportedly resorted to cannibalism of those already dead. When an october snowstorm hit, the party was just 100 miles from their destination. It was widely circulated that members of the party resorted to cannibalism after their food ran out, giving the party its lasting notoriety. Cannibalism has been the donner party s hallmark ever since. In the 1840s a group of pioneers who came to be known as the donner party found themselves trapped in the sierra nevada mountains.
Cannibalismthe ultimate taboois surprisingly common. Donner party cannibalism wasnt a myth its evidence. Survivors said they ate human flesh and rescuers saw the evidence. Analysis of bones discovered at the donner party campsite found no evidence for cannibalism. There is a huge amount of taboo regarding cannibalism among humans, but it is found throughout. Donner partys former camp found may prove cannibalism. Evidence also pointed to one survivor being the perpetrator. In the donner party tragedy, twothirds of the men in the party perished, while twothirds of the women and children lived. Donner party cannibalism wasnt a myth its evidence that starving. The moment they run out of food, someone says, well, i guess well have to eat each other, and they immediately begin working out the details. Tell us about the history of gourmet cannibalism and how mao unleashed a new wave of faminedriven cannibalism during the.
Archaeologists may have found donner party camp news. The archaeologists said that if bone fragments recovered from the 2003 and 2004 alder creek digs turned out to be human, it would be the first physical evidence of cannibalism in the donner party. Analysis of bones discovered at the donner party campsite found no evidence for cannibalism the members did resort to consuming the family dog, cattle, deer and horses. The donner par ty sometimes called the don ner reed party was a group of american pioneers who migrated to california in a wagon train from the midwest. When the final rescue party arrived at the donner camp in april, 1847, lewis keseberg was the only survivor. In order to survive, members of what ended up being called the donner party did indeed turn to survival cannibalism. Archaeologists excavating donner sites havent found any evidence that members participated in cannibalism. While the taboo of cannibalism is the most widely known aspect of the donner party story, most are not as familiar with the circumstances and leadup to the tragedy. Evidence reveals what the donner party ate during their final days of being.
Rightminded historians and history buffs have downplayed the donner party s most memorable feature. It began in 1846, when a group of 87 people set off from missouri to. After eating the family dogs and other animal meat, some members ate bones. If some of the bones are human, they would be the first physical evidence to back up survivors accounts that some members of the donner party resorted to cannibalism. Tamsen donner had been left alive and relatively healthy when the. Donner party researchers find no evidence of cannibalism. News staff the 84 members of the donner party, trapped by a sierra nevada snowstorm on their way to california, did not resort to cannibalism, according to a new analysis of bones found at their alder creek campsite. My 3rd great grandfather, his son george, was rescued by the first relief party and survived. Their initial release said that robbins research finds there is no evidence of cannibalism among the 84 members of the donner party who. Slate pieces and china shards reveal the members tried to live with dignity. The donner party is one of americas best known stories of cannibalism.
The story of how the donner party ended in cannibalism. Isolated in horrific conditions, about half of the original group of nearly 90 people died of starvation or exposure. When the initial appalachian state news release claimed that robbins research found no evidence of cannibalism among the 84 members of the donner party, it was really pulling a fast one. The members did resort to consuming the family dog, cattle, deer and horses. The donner party is an instance where humans turn to cannibalism because of starvation. Their route was supposed to be shorter and faster, but became deadly.
The donner party was a wagon train of about 80 pioneers who set out for california from independence, missouri, in 1846. Donner party cannibalism is not in doubt among anyone who is familiar with the incident. Delayed by a series of mishaps, they spent the winter of 184647 snowbound in the sierra nevada mountain range. Donner party ate family dog, maybe not people technology. The gist evidence reveals what the donner party ate during their final days of being snowbound in the sierra nevada. No evidence for donner party cannibalism, anthropologists. After testing a small sample of the tiny fragments, however, they only identified cattle, horse, deer, dog, rabbit and rodent. When rescue expeditions finally reached the the donner party the next spring, they found evidence of murder and cannibalism. Each party rescued different groups of victims, and each found similar nightmares. New donner party details unearthed by erik stokstad jan. Of course, the money shot in the story is the cannibalism which is, frankly, the least interesting element of the real story of the donner party, and they even manage to botch that. The first party reached donner lake on february 19 and found 12 dead and 48 survivors, barely clinging to life and sanity.
When the relief party went to the donner camp on alder creek, the same situation was encountered with fresh tracks leading back to the lake camp. Donner party pioneers of 1846 forced into cannibalism. The fact that no evidence was found at alder creek doesnt have any reflection on what happened in the entire donner party, johnson said. Courtesy mark mclaughlin after testing a small sample of the tiny fragments, however, they only identified cattle, horse, deer, dog, rabbit and rodent. American chronicles about an archeological examination of the donner family camp in california. A team from the university of oregon dug at a fire pit at the site of the alder creek camp in 200405, but no cooked human bones were found among the animal bone fragments discovered at that site. Thanks to letters and journals kept by members of the donner party and their rescuers, it has long been accepted that cannibalism occurred at the party s main camp at truckee lake later renamed. The tragic story of the donner party legends of america.
Of the thousands of bone fragments uncovered at the donner familys cooking hearth, none were human, dixon said. The donner party was a wagon expedition from illinois to california in 18467 it was also perhaps the most dreadful case ever of mass human cannibalism of the 87 people. Evidence of cooking and the presence of human bone in coprolites fossilized feces have also been used to support a cannibalism hypothesis. The donners are of course most famous for getting snowbound in the sierra mountain in california and resorting to cannibalism to survive as they wintered down in the snow.
It took two months and four relief parties to rescue the entire surviving donner party. The first news of the donner party to reach the world beyond the snowy mountains that trapped them was a sensational tale of starvation, death and cannibalism. The scientists stated that if knifescarred bone fragments recovered there turned out to be human, it would be the first physical evidence of cannibalism in the donner party. In late 1846, 87 immigrants led by george and jacob donner were trapped by heavy snow in the sierra nevada. My parents used to take turns reading the diaries of the donner party when we were driving through the area truckee etc, which was where we usually took vacations, and my dad thought it was the most hilarious thing to go to restaurants and tell the hostess that we were the donners party of 68 or whatever the number was. Cannibalism through human history the earliest evidence for human cannibalism to date has been discovered at the lower paleolithic site of gran dolina spain, where about 780,000 years ago, six.
Don hardesty dug at the murphy cabin site at donner lake in the 1980s without finding gravesites or hard evidence of cannibalism. Keseberg was ultimately accused of murdering six of his fellow donner party members, including tamzene, but was acquitted on each count due to lack of evidence. Donner had first died, afterward his wife, and he had been compelled to eat their flesh to keep from starving. The donner party was a group of 89 emigrants from illinois who purportedly turned to cannibalism to survive after getting trapped by snowfall while on a. New data suggests some cannibalism by ancient indians. The donner party 1846 to 1847 was a group of emigrants moving west to california who became trapped while crossing the sierra nevada mountains. Donner party, group of american pioneers stranded en route to california in 1846. Donner party s former camp found may prove cannibalism groups possible hearth discovered outside truckee thomas h. Tracking down the truth of what happened to the donner party. Donner party cannibalism controversy still being investigated. Cannibalism took place at four different sites with different groups from the original party, johnson said, and alder creek was a site that saw cannibalism for a short period. Donner party ate family dog, maybe not people seeker. Heres what happened to the survivors of the donner party.
655 573 865 1215 628 1333 1137 1093 787 1274 1002 457 1133 1515 575 637 870 1475 1181 661 1180 363 595 1239 1464 1047 1495 329 52 184 218 1095